On March 5, 2026, a Los Angeles judge refused to dismiss producer Jonathan Hay's civil suit against Sean Combs. On April 21, 2026, a New York judge dismissed Combs's own $100 million defamation suit against NBCUniversal. Both rulings were reported under headlines built on the word dismiss, and they mean nearly opposite things. Each term below is tied to a dated ruling in a case this site tracks.
Motion to dismiss denied
A motion to dismiss is usually a defendant's first move. It asks the judge to end the case before any evidence is exchanged, on the ground that the complaint, read as written, does not state a claim the law recognizes. No witnesses testify at this stage, and the judge does not decide who is telling the truth. A denial means the claims are legally sufficient as pleaded. They are not proven. The case moves on to discovery, where each side gathers documents and testimony.
Hay first sued in July 2025 as a John Doe and later identified himself. His suit alleges incidents in Los Angeles in 2020 and 2021. Combs and several of his companies asked the Los Angeles Superior Court to dismiss it, and a March 5, 2026 minute order denied that request, according to court documents reported by Keeping Tabs (Radar) on March 12, 2026. The claims remain allegations. Combs's attorney has said that Combs “categorically denies as false and defamatory all claims that he sexually abused anyone.” Our update on the Hay ruling lists the reports it rests on.
Dismissed, with or without prejudice
When a judge grants a motion to dismiss, the case, or the part of it the motion targeted, ends in that court. The order matters more than the headline. A dismissal with prejudice is final on those claims, and they cannot be filed again. A dismissal without prejudice leaves room to amend the complaint or refile it.
Combs sued NBCUniversal in February 2025 in New York Supreme Court, New York County, which despite its name is a state trial court, over the Peacock documentary “Diddy: The Making of a Bad Boy.” On April 21, 2026, Justice Phaedra F. Perry-Bond granted NBCUniversal's motion to dismiss, applying New York's anti-SLAPP law and the libel-proof plaintiff doctrine, according to Billboard and Deadline. The reports this site has read do not say whether the dismissal was with or without prejudice, or whether Combs has appealed. NBCUniversal is seeking about $990,000 in legal fees under the anti-SLAPP law, according to a report of August 28, 2026 (our update on the dismissal).
Combs was the plaintiff in that case, so the ruling decides nothing about any claim made against him.
Certiorari denied
Most cases reach the U.S. Supreme Court by a petition for a writ of certiorari, a request that the Court agree to hear an appeal. The Court decides a small fraction of the petitions it receives. When it denies one, it has refused to hear the case. A denial is not a ruling on the merits and not an endorsement of the decision below, but it leaves that decision in place.
In Trump v. Carroll, No. 25-573, the Court denied certiorari on June 29, 2026, and denied rehearing on August 17, 2026. That ended the appeals of the $5 million judgment from the 2023 trial, which the Second Circuit had affirmed on December 30, 2024. It did not end the litigation. A separate $83.3 million defamation judgment from 2024 is the subject of two more petitions, Nos. 26-141 and 26-142, filed on July 28, 2026, with responses due October 30, 2026, according to the docket as checked on October 5, 2026. Trump denies Carroll's claims (our update on the Carroll denial).
In Lujan Claimants v. Boy Scouts of America, No. 25-490, 75 survivors asked the Court to review the Boy Scouts bankruptcy plan, arguing that it wrongly blocks them from suing local councils and chartering organizations. BSA argued in its brief in opposition, filed December 4, 2025, that the plan could not lawfully be unwound. The Court denied certiorari on January 12, 2026. Earlier, on May 13, 2025, the Third Circuit had dismissed the survivors' appeals under section 363(m) of the Bankruptcy Code, which protects a court-approved sale that was not stayed pending appeal, without deciding whether the plan's releases of those organizations were lawful (our update on the Boy Scouts denial).
No appeals court has ruled on whether those particular releases were lawful.
Verdict and judgment
A verdict is the jury's decision. A judgment is the court's order that turns it into an enforceable obligation, and it is the judgment that gets appealed. A civil jury decides by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely than not, which is a lower bar than the criminal standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. A civil verdict finds a defendant liable. It is not a criminal conviction, and our guide to civil and criminal cases sets out the differences.
The Carroll case shows the sequence. Trial ran from April 25 to May 8, 2023, in the Southern District of New York before Judge Lewis A. Kaplan. On May 9, 2023, a unanimous nine-person jury found that Trump sexually abused E. Jean Carroll in 1996 and defamed her in 2022 statements, and found that she had not shown he “raped” her. The court entered judgment for $5 million on May 11, 2023, and denied a motion for a new trial on July 19, 2023. Trump did not testify at trial and has denied the allegations. Because a jury made a finding, this site describes the 2023 claim as a finding of civil liability rather than an allegation, and states his denial beside it.
Carroll's claim arose decades before she sued. It reached court through New York's Adult Survivors Act, CPLR 214-j, which opened a one-year filing window on November 24, 2022, and she filed minutes after it opened.
Settled, without an admission
A settlement is a contract. The defendant pays, and the claimants release their claims. Many settlements say the defendant admits nothing, and this site treats such a settlement as neither an admission of liability nor an exoneration. It ends the dispute without deciding it.
A class settlement adds a step, because it binds people who were never in the courtroom. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, a judge approves it in two stages: preliminary approval so that notice can go out, then final approval after class members have had the chance to object or opt out, and only on a finding that the deal is “fair, reasonable, and adequate.” In Doe 3 v. Indyke, No. 1:24-cv-01204, in the Southern District of New York, the co-executors of Jeffrey Epstein's estate, his former lawyer Darren K. Indyke and former accountant Richard D. Kahn, agreed to a class settlement of up to $35 million. The unopposed motion for preliminary approval was filed on February 19, 2026, and Judge Arun Subramanian granted preliminary approval on March 3, 2026. An objection was filed on August 26, 2026. After a hearing on September 16, 2026, the court ordered further notice to the class and set the final approval hearing for December 2, 2026, so the settlement can still change or fail.
The suit alleges that Indyke and Kahn helped build the financial structure of Epstein's trafficking operation. Those are the plaintiffs' allegations. The defendants' lawyer said neither man “admitted wrongdoing or conceded misconduct,” according to Reuters on March 3, 2026 (our update on the settlement).
Checking a ruling for yourself
The order itself, and the docket around it, says more than a headline. Four details settle most of the confusion.
- Who brought the motion or the suit. Combs's motion to dismiss was denied in March 2026, and his own suit was dismissed in April 2026. Only the first concerns claims against him.
- Whether a dismissal is with or without prejudice, and whether it covers the whole case or only some claims.
- Whether an approval is preliminary or final. The Epstein estate settlement had preliminary approval on March 3, 2026, and its final approval hearing is set for December 2, 2026.
- Which judgment a Supreme Court order covers. The June 29, 2026 denial in Carroll reached the $5 million judgment, not the $83.3 million one.
The high-profile case tracker gives the court and docket for each matter, and the editorial process page sets out how this site words them: allegations stay allegations until a court finds otherwise, and a defendant's denial sits beside the conduct it answers.
Questions we are asked most
No. It means the claims, as written in the complaint, are legally sufficient to go forward to discovery. When a Los Angeles judge refused on March 5, 2026 to dismiss Jonathan Hay's suit against Sean Combs, the claims stayed allegations, and Combs denies them.
No. A denial of certiorari is a refusal to hear the case, not a ruling on the merits. It does leave the lower court's decision in place, which is what happened to the 2023 Carroll verdict on June 29, 2026 and to the Boy Scouts bankruptcy plan on January 12, 2026.
A dismissal with prejudice ends those claims for good, and they cannot be filed again. A dismissal without prejudice leaves room to amend the complaint or refile it. The news reports on the April 21, 2026 dismissal of Combs's suit against NBCUniversal do not say which kind it was.
Not when the settlement says otherwise. A settlement without an admission is neither an admission of liability nor an exoneration. In the proposed Epstein estate class settlement of up to $35 million, the defendants' lawyer said on March 3, 2026 that neither man admitted wrongdoing or conceded misconduct.
No. A civil jury decides whether a defendant is liable, usually by a preponderance of the evidence, and the remedy is money. Only a criminal court can convict, and it must find guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A person found liable in a civil case is still presumed innocent of any crime unless convicted.
More from the blog
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 25-573, Trump v. Carroll (certiorari denied June 29, 2026; rehearing denied August 17, 2026) Accurate as of August 17, 2026.
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 26-141, Trump v. Carroll (petition filed July 28, 2026) Accurate as of October 5, 2026.
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 26-142, United States v. Carroll (petition filed July 28, 2026) Accurate as of October 5, 2026.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, Carroll v. Trump, No. 23-793, opinion affirming the 2023 judgment (December 30, 2024) Accurate as of December 30, 2024.
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 25-490, Lujan Claimants v. Boy Scouts of America (certiorari denied January 12, 2026) Accurate as of January 12, 2026.
- Brief for the Scouting Respondents in Opposition, No. 25-490 (December 4, 2025): petitioners are 75 survivors Accurate as of December 4, 2025.
- In re Boy Scouts of America, Third Circuit No. 23-1664, opinion (May 13, 2025) Accurate as of May 13, 2025.
- Doe 3 v. Indyke, No. 1:24-cv-01204-AS (S.D.N.Y.), docket Accurate as of September 17, 2026.
- Doe 3 v. Indyke, Memo endorsement, Dkt. 446 (September 17, 2026): notice program and final approval hearing December 2, 2026 Accurate as of September 17, 2026.
- Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279 (1991): preponderance of the evidence as the general civil standard
- In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358 (1970): proof beyond a reasonable doubt required for a criminal conviction
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, class actions: notice and exclusion (23(c)(2)(B)) and settlement approval (23(e))
- New York CPLR 214-j, Adult Survivors Act revival window
- Keeping Tabs (Radar), "Read the documents: Sean Diddy Combs" (March 12, 2026) (news reporting) Accurate as of March 12, 2026.
- Radar via AOL, Combs's attorney's statement (news reporting) Accurate as of March 12, 2026.
- Billboard, "Diddy can't sue NBC over Biggie and Kim Porter death claims" (April 2026) (news reporting) Accurate as of April 21, 2026.
- Deadline, "Sean Combs NBC lawsuit dismissed" (April 2026) (news reporting) Accurate as of April 21, 2026.
- V101.9, "NBCUniversal seeks nearly $1 million in legal fees from Diddy" (August 28, 2026) (news reporting) Accurate as of August 28, 2026.
- Reuters via Yahoo, "US judge preliminarily approves $35 million" (March 3, 2026) (news reporting) Accurate as of March 3, 2026.